Car and Driver's ranking is based on the results of large-scale instrument testing of hundreds of vehicle models every year, as well as the subjective feelings of our senior editors in real road driving. When we selected the best pickup truck, we referred to approximately 200 data points, covering acceleration performance, handling, comfort, cargo space, fuel economy, cost performance and driving pleasure. We are very strict about rankings because we want you to have a comprehensive understanding of every car you are interested in.